The 4 types of team culture according to Cameron and Quinn
Two teams can have the same org chart and work in opposite ways. The Competing Values Framework explains that difference with just two questions, and four team cultures grow out of them.
Two axes, flexibility and focus, sort any team
In 1983, Robert Quinn and John Rohrbaugh asked a group of researchers to compare the criteria usually used to judge whether an organization works well. When those opinions were sorted, a few underlying dimensions emerged. Two of them are the ones used today to describe culture:
- Flexibility versus stability. Does the team give people room to decide and change, or does it prefer predictable processes and control?
- Internal versus external focus. Does it look mainly inward (people, coordination) or outward (clients, users, competitors)?
Later, Kim Cameron and Robert Quinn applied the scheme to organizational culture in Diagnosing and Changing Organizational Culture, whose third edition dates from 2011. Crossing the two axes gives four quadrants, each corresponding to a culture.
Clan, adhocracy, market and hierarchy, with an example of each
Clan: the collaborative culture
Flexible and focused on people. The team resembles a close-knit group: decisions are discussed, the atmosphere is looked after and those who know more teach newcomers.
Example: a ward nursing team that covers each other’s shifts without being asked and talks through the difficult cases at the end of the day.
Adhocracy: the innovative culture
Flexible and attentive to the outside world. The team tries out ideas before all the answers are in, and roles change from project to project. The name comes from ad hoc: structures designed for each situation.
Example: a small team develops an educational app, tests it with a group of teachers and rebuilds it in two weeks based on what it hears.
Market: the results-focused culture
Stable and outward-looking. There are clear goals, they are reviewed with data and achieving them is celebrated. “Market” does not mean selling: it refers to an orientation toward external results and comparison with others.
Example: a store team that reviews sales and customer feedback every Monday and adjusts the peak-hour shifts.
Hierarchy: the process-focused culture
Stable and focused on internal coordination. There are procedures for almost everything and everyone knows what their part is. “Hierarchy” does not mean authoritarianism either: it describes reliable rules and processes.
Example: a clinical laboratory that follows the same protocol for every analysis and records each step.
Cultures on opposite diagonals pursue opposing values
That is where the model gets its name, and where its most useful part lies: the diagonals. Each culture faces the one that pursues the opposite values on both axes at once:
- Clan versus market. People and cohesion versus numbers and competition. An individual productivity ranking can clash with a team used to helping each other: for some it is an incentive, for others a threat to the atmosphere.
- Adhocracy versus hierarchy. Change and improvisation versus order and predictability. Someone suggests trying a new tool and the answer is “first we need to update the protocol”: some see prudence, others a brake.
For Cameron and Quinn, these tensions are not a flaw to be eliminated. An organization needs all four types of values to different degrees, and what changes from one team to another is the weight of each. That is why the same team often shows features from several quadrants at once.
This idea of opposing values on a single map is reminiscent of the one Shalom Schwartz applied to personal values, explained in Schwartz’s 10 values. The difference is one of level: Schwartz talks about what matters to each person, Cameron and Quinn about how a group works.
Two meta-analyses support the map, not all of its predictions
The model is one of the most widely used for studying organizational culture, but it is worth separating what is supported from what is not:
- What holds up. The meta-analysis by Chad Hartnell, Amy Ou and Angelo Kinicki (2011) pooled 84 studies with 94 independent samples. It found that clan, adhocracy and market cultures are positively associated with effectiveness indicators such as employee attitudes, innovation, quality and financial results.
- What holds up less. Those relationships did not always follow the pattern the model predicts, and the study did not fully confirm how the four cultures relate to each other. The authors proposed an alternative way of understanding the framework.
- A note on the origin. Quinn and Rohrbaugh’s 1983 work was about effectiveness criteria, not culture. The cultural reading came later, with Cameron and Quinn.
What each study measured, from 1981 to 2019
We have gathered the work behind the model in one table, with what each study looked at and the data it relied on.
| Year | Work | What it studied | Basis | What it contributed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1981 | Quinn & Rohrbaugh, Public Productivity Review | First presentation of the approach | Theoretical proposal | The idea of competing values applied to effectiveness |
| 1983 | Quinn & Rohrbaugh, Management Science | Criteria of organizational effectiveness | Researchers’ judgments | The flexibility-stability and internal-external axes |
| 1999 and 2011 | Cameron & Quinn, Diagnosing and Changing Organizational Culture (1st and 3rd eds.) | Organizational culture | The OCAI questionnaire | The four cultures: clan, adhocracy, market and hierarchy |
| 2011 | Hartnell, Ou & Kinicki | Three cultures (clan, adhocracy and market) against employee attitudes, operational performance and financial results | 84 studies, 94 samples | Positive associations, not always the predicted ones |
| 2019 | Hartnell, Ou, Kinicki, Choi & Karam | Culture alongside strategy, structure, leadership and high-performance work practices | 148 samples, 26,196 organizations and 556,945 informants | Culture explains part of effectiveness on its own, even after accounting for leadership and practices |
Three takeaways from the table:
- The broadest evidence is the 2019 study, with data from more than 26,000 organizations: culture adds something of its own to outcomes, though its weight varies by indicator.
- The 2011 meta-analysis left hierarchy out. Its conclusions about effectiveness refer to the other three cultures.
- Both meta-analyses measure organizations, not specific teams. Applying their figures to a five-person team calls for caution.
The practical conclusion is cautious: the model works well as a map for conversation about how a team works, and less well as a closed theory with exact predictions.
One answer is a single view; several make a portrait of the team
Cameron and Quinn created their own questionnaire, the OCAI, which is copyrighted. The team culture test uses original statements on the same two axes and places you in one of the four quadrants, with the opposite culture and the typical tension between the two.
One person’s answers reflect only their own experience. That is why the test lets several people from the same team pool their results anonymously and see where they agree. And if you are more interested in what you look for in a job than in how your team works, the test What do I value most in a job? measures that instead.
Sources
- Cameron, K. S., & Quinn, R. E. (2011). Diagnosing and Changing Organizational Culture: Based on the Competing Values Framework (3rd ed.). Jossey-Bass.
- Hartnell, C. A., Ou, A. Y., & Kinicki, A. (2011). Organizational culture and organizational effectiveness: A meta-analytic investigation of the competing values framework’s theoretical suppositions. Journal of Applied Psychology, 96(4), 677-694. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0021987
- Quinn, R. E., & Rohrbaugh, J. (1983). A spatial model of effectiveness criteria: Towards a competing values approach to organizational analysis. Management Science, 29(3), 363-377. https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.29.3.363
- Hartnell, C. A., Ou, A. Y., Kinicki, A. J., Choi, D. & Karam, E. P. (2019). A meta-analytic test of organizational culture’s association with elements of an organization’s system and its relative predictive validity on organizational outcomes. Journal of Applied Psychology, 104(6), 832-850. https://doi.org/10.1037/apl0000380
- Quinn, R. E. & Rohrbaugh, J. (1981). A competing values approach to organizational effectiveness. Public Productivity Review, 5(2), 122-140. https://doi.org/10.2307/3380029
Want to know more about yourself?
Discover your result with one of our related tests.
Frequently asked questions
How does Cameron and Quinn's OCAI questionnaire work?
The OCAI (Organizational Culture Assessment Instrument) covers six aspects of an organization, such as its dominant characteristics, leadership style and criteria of success. Each one comes with four descriptions, one per culture, and the respondent divides 100 points among them. They answer twice: once for the organization as it is now and once for how they would like it to be. The gap between the two profiles is the starting point of the change process the authors propose.