Personaramic
Teams and leadership

Tuckman's 5 stages, from forming to adjourning

By Personaramic Editorial7 min read
Geometric illustration of five circles in a row, each with the dots inside more orderly than the last, and the final one opening up

A team does not work the same way in its first month as in its eighth. In 1965, Bruce Tuckman gave that change a name: forming, storming, norming and performing. Twelve years later he added a fifth stage, adjourning.

The model comes from reviewing 50 studies, not from observing one team

Tuckman did not observe one particular team. His boss at a US Navy research center, Irwin Altman, had been collecting articles on group development for some time and handed him the collection.

There were 50 articles, on four types of groups: therapy groups, training groups, natural groups (such as those in a company) and laboratory groups. He looked for what they had in common and saw that the same sequence recurred in almost all of them.

His proposal, published in Psychological Bulletin, separated two planes that move forward at the same time:

  • Relationships: how the people in the group treat each other.
  • The task: how they organize themselves to get the work done.

The stages were given rhyming names (forming, storming, norming, performing), which makes them easy to remember.

In 1977, Tuckman and Mary Ann Jensen reviewed the studies from the following decade and added adjourning: the group’s ending.

The five stages, seen in a single team

To see it in action, let us follow an invented team: five neighbors whom the city council asks to organize the neighborhood’s first film festival. They have eight months.

1. Forming: everyone polite, nobody sure

At the first meeting, Martha, who coordinates, explains the assignment. The others nod, ask few questions and nobody disagrees. On the way out, each of them has a different idea of what was agreed.

Tuckman describes this stage as orientation: the group explores the task, tests the boundaries and depends heavily on whoever coordinates. Courtesy is high and clarity is low.

2. Storming: differences come to light

In the second month, Louis wants classic films and Anna wants shorts by local people. They argue about who decides the program and whether Martha should have the final say.

This is storming. For Tuckman, this tension is a normal response to the demands of the task: it appears once people feel confident enough to speak their minds. It is the moment when the group works through its differences.

3. Norming: the team finds its way of working

By the fourth month, they have agreed, without writing it down, that the program is put to a vote and that each person handles one area. Disagreements still exist, but they are voiced calmly and resolved.

Tuckman talks about cohesion: the group accepts its roles, creates its own norms and begins to exchange opinions openly.

4. Performing: energy goes into the work

In the sixth month, a sound equipment supplier cancels two weeks before the festival. Nobody calls a meeting: Anna phones another one, Louis readjusts the budget and Martha finds out through the group chat once it is already sorted.

At this stage, according to Tuckman, the group’s structure serves the task. Roles are flexible and problems are solved within the team.

5. Adjourning: the ending

The festival is over. The team has a dinner, goes over what went well and goes its separate ways. This is the stage Tuckman and Jensen added: a group with an end date also experiences its ending as a stage in its own right.

An important nuance: if two new neighbors join the following year, the team will probably go through forming and storming again. The stages are not a one-way road.

Tuckman's five stages of group developmentForming. Politeness, questions and reliance on the coordinator. Storming. Methods, roles and leadership are debated. Norming. Shared agreements and cohesion. Performing. Structure serves the task. Adjourning. The task ends and the group disbands1FormingPoliteness, questions and reliance on thecoordinator2StormingMethods, roles and leadership are debated3NormingShared agreements and cohesion4PerformingStructure serves the task5AdjourningThe task ends and the group disbands
Tuckman (1965) proposed the first four; Tuckman and Jensen (1977) added adjourning. It is a typical sequence: a team can slip back to an earlier stage.

The evidence is more modest than the model’s fame

  • It has rarely been tested directly. In their 1977 review, Tuckman and Jensen found 22 related studies, and only one had set out to test it directly.
  • Not all teams follow the sequence. Connie Gersick studied eight real project teams and in 1988 published an alternative model, punctuated equilibrium. According to her observations, teams set a direction in their first meeting, keep it during the first half of their deadline and make a shift around the midpoint of the available time.
  • It was born from very specific groups. Denise Bonebright (2010) looked back over forty years of the model’s history and points out that many of the original studies were of therapy groups, not work teams.

Gersick does not deny that there is conflict or that norms form. What she questions is that they arrive in that order and in stages. In the festival example, her model would focus on the fourth month: the midpoint of the deadline, when the team notices time is running out and shifts gear.

The two models agree at the start and the end, and part ways in the middle

We placed both models on the same calendar: the festival’s eight months. The Tuckman column follows the stages in the example; the Gersick column applies what she observed in her eight teams (a framework set at the first meeting, a transition at the midpoint and a final push before the deadline).

MonthTuckman’s readingGersick’s reading
1Forming: politeness and orientationFirst meeting: the team adopts, almost without saying so, an approach that will last for months
2-3Storming: arguments over programming and leadershipFirst phase of inertia: work goes on within that initial approach
4Norming: agreements on how to decideMidpoint transition: old routines are dropped, the team re-engages with the city council and makes a leap
5-7Performing: problems solved within the teamSecond phase of inertia: the revised plan is carried out
8Adjourning after the festivalA final push before the deadline

The difference lies in what drives change:

  • For Tuckman, the engine is relationships: the group matures as members get to know each other and negotiate.
  • For Gersick, the engine is the clock: in her teams, the shift came around the halfway point of the time available, prompted more by awareness of the deadline than by the work already done.

Both readings can coexist. A team could use Tuckman’s vocabulary to talk about how it gets along and, at the same time, set aside a moment near the midpoint to review the approach chosen on day one, which is when Gersick saw teams change course.

It works as a map, not as a timetable

As a descriptive map, it works well. It provides a shared vocabulary for talking about something almost everyone has experienced: new teams are clumsy, early arguments usually pass and a good team can be thrown off balance by a single change.

What it should not be used for is a timetable (“we should be performing by now”) or a judgment on the team. No stage is a failure: each one describes a moment.

If you want to put a name to your group’s current moment, the team stage test measures the first four stages based on observable situations, and several people from the same team can pool their results anonymously. To see the part you play within that group, there is the team role test.

Sources

  • Tuckman, B. W. (1965). Developmental sequence in small groups. Psychological Bulletin, 63(6), 384-399. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0022100
  • Tuckman, B. W., & Jensen, M. A. C. (1977). Stages of small-group development revisited. Group & Organization Studies, 2(4), 419-427. https://doi.org/10.1177/105960117700200404
  • Tuckman, B. W. (1984). This Week’s Citation Classic: Developmental sequence in small groups. Current Contents, 34, 14.
  • Gersick, C. J. G. (1988). Time and transition in work teams: Toward a new model of group development. Academy of Management Journal, 31(1), 9-41. https://doi.org/10.2307/256496
  • Bonebright, D. A. (2010). 40 years of storming: A historical review of Tuckman’s model of small group development. Human Resource Development International, 13(1), 111-120. https://doi.org/10.1080/13678861003589099

Want to know more about yourself?

Discover your result with one of our related tests.

Frequently asked questions

How long does each of Tuckman's stages last?

The model sets no durations. In Connie Gersick's 1988 study, the teams' deadlines ranged from a few days to several months, and the change of direction still came around the midpoint of the available time. That suggests the pace depends more on each team's deadline than on a common timetable.

Was Tuckman's article accepted the first time?

No. As Tuckman himself recounted in 1984, Lloyd Humphreys, then editor of Psychological Bulletin, rejected it because he doubted the quality of the studies it reviewed. Tuckman rewrote it and argued that he was not vouching for those studies, only drawing conclusions from them. That second version is the one published in 1965.